1950-1951 - 1953-1954 Seasons
1950-1951 Season
- Main Stage:
- Blithe Spirit - Noel Coward
- The Skin of our Teeth - Thorton Wilder
- The Indian Captive - author unknown
- From Morn to Night - Georg Kaiser
- Goodbye My Fancy - Gertruse Stein
- Jack and the Beanstalk - Charles Lundlam
- The Time of Your Life - William Sarovan
- Arena Theatre:
- The Enchanted - Jean Giraudoux
- How the Starts were Made - author unknown
- The Corn is Green - Emlyn Williams
- The Imaginary Invalid - Moliere
1951-1952 Season
- Main Stage:
- Miss Julie - August Strindberg
- Green Grow the Lilacs - Lynn Riggs
- Playboy of the Western World - Synge & Duffy
- The Ghost of Mr. Penny - author unknown
- Rose without a Thorn - Clifford Bax
- The Emperors New Clothes - Charlotte Chorpenning
- Skylark - Samson Raphelson
- Arena Theatre:
- For Love or Money - F. Hugh Herbert
- Beyond the Horizon - Eugene ONeill
1952-1953 Season
- Main Stage:
- Ah, Wilderness! - Eugene ONeill
- A Sleep of Prisoners - author unknown
- Heidi - Wendy Wasserstein
- She Stoops to Conquer - Oliver Goldsmith
- Simple Simon - Wynn, Bolter, Hart & Rogers
- A Dolls House - Henrik Ibsen
- Arena Theatre:
- The Women Have Their Way - Sutro & Alvarez
- Just for the Fun of It - author unknown
- The Grass Harp - Truman Capote
1953-1954 Season
- Main Stage:
- Beauty and the Beast - Jaqueline Wilson
- The Winters Tale - William Shakespeare
- Tom Sawyer - Paul Kester
- Cinderella - author unknown
- Arena Theatre:
- Arms and the Man - George Bernard Shaw
- The Man Who Came to Dinner - Kaufman & Hart
- Heartbreak House - George bernard Shaw
- Elizabeth the Queen - Maxwell Andreson
- Theta Alpha Phi Production:
- Rumpelstiltskin - Norman Robbins
- Medea - Euripides
- Mr. Dooley, Jr. - author unknown
- Escape - John Glasworthy
- Gramercy Ghost - John Cecil Holm